Back to Vitamins

Which Is Better, Vitamin D2 or Vitamin D3?

Which Is Better, Vitamin D2 or Vitamin D3?
Supplements Guide 11 March 2026

Vitamin D on a label comes in two forms. D3, or cholecalciferol, is the form your skin makes from sunlight and the form found in animal foods. D2, or ergocalciferol, comes from fungi and yeast exposed to ultraviolet light. Both raise blood vitamin D, and most direct comparisons find D3 does it more effectively.

How different are they in practice?

Once either form is absorbed, the liver converts it to 25-hydroxyvitamin D, which is the storage form measured in a blood test. The difference lies in how efficiently that happens and how long the result lasts.

Trials comparing equal doses have generally found D3 produces a higher rise and sustains it for longer. Meta-analyses pooling those studies have reported the same direction of effect, with the gap widening when doses are given weekly or monthly rather than daily.

The proposed explanation is that 25-hydroxyvitamin D2 is cleared from circulation faster and binds less tightly to the protein that carries vitamin D around the body. There is also some evidence that D2 slightly accelerates the breakdown of existing D3 stores.

None of this makes D2 useless. It is a genuine source of vitamin D, it has been used to treat deficiency for decades, and it works. It simply requires a somewhat larger dose to achieve the same measured result, and the difference shrinks when both are taken daily.

Where does each one come from?

  • D3 from lanolin, the grease in sheep wool, which is the source in most mainstream supplements
  • D3 from fish liver oil, used in cod liver oil products and some capsules
  • D3 from lichen, a plant based source that is fully suitable for vegans
  • D2 from yeast or mushrooms treated with ultraviolet light

Lanolin derived D3 is vegetarian in the sense that no animal is killed for it, and many vegetarians are comfortable with it. It is not vegan. That distinction used to force vegans towards D2, and it no longer does, because lichen derived D3 is now widely available and reasonably priced.

Do mushrooms count as a source?

They can, with a caveat about how they were grown. Mushrooms produce D2 when exposed to ultraviolet light, and commercially grown mushrooms are usually raised in the dark, so ordinary supermarket mushrooms contain very little.

Some producers deliberately expose mushrooms to UV and label them accordingly, and those do contain useful amounts. Leaving mushrooms on a sunny windowsill has been shown to increase their D2 content, though how much depends on the season, the surface area exposed and the strength of the light, which makes it an unreliable strategy in a British winter.

Which should you buy?

For most people D3 is the sensible default, on the straightforward grounds that it achieves the intended result more reliably at the same dose and costs no more.

For vegans, lichen derived D3 is the better option than D2 for the same reason. Check the label states lichen or vegan D3 specifically, since a product marked suitable for vegetarians may well be lanolin based.

D2 remains a reasonable choice if it is what you have, what your prescription specifies, or what suits your circumstances. High dose D2 is still used medically to treat confirmed deficiency, and prescribed treatment should be followed as directed rather than swapped on the basis of an article.

Does the format matter as much as the form?

Less than the marketing implies. Sprays and liquids are frequently sold at a premium on the argument that absorption through the mouth bypasses digestion, and comparative studies have generally found sprays and tablets produce broadly similar blood levels.

Where format genuinely helps is with swallowing difficulty, with children, and with anyone who has had bariatric surgery or has a condition affecting fat absorption, in which case a liquid or a medically advised route may be appropriate.

Whichever you choose, the dose is what matters most. UK guidance describes 10 micrograms, equal to 400 international units, daily for the general population in autumn and winter, and year round for people in higher risk groups.

This article is general information and not medical advice. Ask a pharmacist or GP before starting a supplement if you take prescribed medicine or have a health condition.