Does Calcium Cause Kidney Stones?
Dietary calcium reduces stone risk while supplements appear to increase it. This is counterintuitive and one of the more useful findings in the whole subject.
Where supplements help and where diet does it better, plus the cardiovascular questions raised about high doses.
Dietary calcium reduces stone risk while supplements appear to increase it. This is counterintuitive and one of the more useful findings in the whole subject.
A narrower group than the shelf suggests. Most UK adults meet requirements from food, and supplements make sense where intake is genuinely low or absorption is impaired.
It binds several widely prescribed medicines in the gut, and some medicines raise or lower calcium in return. Levothyroxine is the most commonly missed.
Split into doses of 500mg or less, with meals if you take carbonate. Spacing from iron, zinc and several medicines matters more than the time of day.
Excess causes constipation first and raised blood calcium later, with kidney stones and kidney damage as the serious consequences. Supplements rather than food are almost always responsible.
Vitamin D controls how much calcium you absorb, so a deficiency limits what a calcium supplement can achieve. The trials showing fracture benefit generally used both together.
Comfortably, provided the replacements are deliberate. The common failure is dropping dairy without substituting anything, which is how intakes fall by half.
Carbonate is cheap and needs stomach acid, so it must be taken with food. Citrate absorbs without acid and suits older adults and anyone on acid reducing medicines.
Horse chestnut extract is taken for varicose veins and leg swelling, and has better evidence than most herbal supplements for that use.
Some analyses suggested a modest increase in heart attacks with calcium supplements, and the question remains genuinely unresolved. Dietary calcium shows no such association.
Red clover supplies isoflavones and is taken for hot flushes and bone health. Meta-analyses have found small and inconsistent effects.
The trials are less encouraging than the marketing. Benefits appear mainly in older adults with low intakes taking calcium alongside vitamin D, rather than in the general population.