Black cohosh is among the most widely used herbal supplements for menopausal symptoms and carries a specific safety warning on UK packaging.
What is black cohosh?
The root of Actaea racemosa, a North American plant used traditionally by indigenous peoples and later adopted in European herbal medicine.
Black cohosh is not a phytoestrogen, despite frequently being grouped with soy and red clover, and its mechanism remains unclear.
What do people take it for?
Hot flushes and night sweats during the menopause, most often by women who cannot or prefer not to take hormone replacement therapy.
It also appears in general menopause support products alongside sage, red clover and vitamins.
What does the research show?
Trials of black cohosh for hot flushes have produced mixed results, with some reporting reductions and others finding no benefit over placebo.
Reviews have generally concluded that the evidence is insufficient to recommend it, while noting that some women report improvement.
Placebo responses in hot flush trials are large, which makes interpretation harder.
What is the liver concern?
Cases of liver injury associated with black cohosh have been reported internationally, some serious.
UK products carry a warning to stop taking it and seek medical advice if signs of liver problems develop.
Warning signs include jaundice, dark urine, unusual tiredness, nausea and abdominal pain.
Who should avoid black cohosh?
- Anyone pregnant, since it has traditional use affecting the uterus
- Anyone breastfeeding
- People with existing liver disease
- Anyone taking other products with liver injury reports
- Women with hormone sensitive cancer, without discussing it with their team
How long should it be taken?
Guidance generally suggests limiting continuous use to around six months, with review thereafter.
Many people take it considerably longer without that being reconsidered.
What are the alternatives?
Hormone replacement therapy has strong evidence for menopausal symptoms and is appropriate for many women.
Non-hormonal prescribed options exist where HRT is unsuitable.
Cognitive behavioural therapy has evidence for hot flushes and for sleep and mood symptoms.
What should you do?
Discuss menopausal symptoms with a GP, since the range of options is wider than it was and includes several worth considering before a supplement.
What is the summary?
Black cohosh is taken for hot flushes, has mixed evidence, carries liver warnings on UK packaging and should be avoided in pregnancy.
This article is general information and not medical advice.
What dose is used?
Trials have generally used extract equivalent to around 40 milligrams of dried root daily, over eight to twelve weeks.
Products vary, and standardisation is inconsistent across the category.
Does it affect hormones?
Early assumptions that black cohosh acted as a phytoestrogen have not been supported, and its mechanism remains unclear.
That uncertainty is part of why advice for women with hormone sensitive cancer remains cautious.
What are the common side effects?
Stomach upset, headache, rash and weight changes have all been reported, generally mild.
The liver signal is the concern that distinguishes it from most menopause supplements.
Who might it suit?
Someone with menopausal symptoms who cannot take HRT, has no liver problems, and has discussed it with a GP.
Reviewing after a few months rather than continuing indefinitely is sensible.
What should you watch for?
Jaundice, dark urine, persistent nausea, unusual tiredness or upper abdominal pain, all of which mean stopping and seeking advice.
The warning is on the packaging for a reason.
What is the evidence position overall?
Mixed efficacy findings alongside a genuine safety signal, which is a poor combination for any product.
It remains widely sold and widely used.
The warning on the packet is the part worth reading.
Does it interact with medicines?
Interactions have been proposed with several medicines metabolised by the liver, and evidence is limited.
Anyone on regular medication should check before starting black cohosh.