Mineral labelling contains a trap that catches almost everyone at least once, because two very different numbers can both appear on the same packet.
What is the issue?
Minerals are supplied as compounds, since pure minerals are not stable or absorbable.
Only part of the compound weight is the mineral itself, and the proportion varies enormously between compounds.
What are the proportions?
- Magnesium oxide is around 60 per cent elemental magnesium
- Magnesium citrate is around 16 per cent
- Calcium carbonate is around 40 per cent elemental calcium
- Calcium citrate is around 21 per cent
- Zinc gluconate is around 14 per cent elemental zinc
- Iron sulfate is around 20 per cent elemental iron
How does this mislead?
A product stating 400 milligrams of magnesium citrate supplies around 64 milligrams of magnesium.
A product stating 400 milligrams of magnesium oxide supplies around 240 milligrams.
The first number looks identical and the actual content differs by a factor of nearly four.
Which figure should you use?
The elemental amount, which is what reference values and upper limits refer to.
Labels are required to state the nutrient amount, which should be the elemental figure, and marketing sometimes leads with the compound weight instead.
Does absorption complicate it?
Yes. Magnesium oxide contains more elemental magnesium and is absorbed less well than citrate or glycinate.
So the compound with more elemental content may deliver less, which is why form matters alongside quantity.
How do you compare products?
Find the elemental amount per serving for each, and compare those figures rather than the compound weights on the front.
What is the summary?
Compound weight and mineral content are different numbers, sometimes differing several fold. The elemental figure is the only one worth comparing.
This article is general information and not medical advice.
Should labels always state elemental content?
Labelling rules require the nutrient amount to be declared, which means the elemental figure.
Marketing on the front frequently uses the larger compound weight because it looks more impressive.
How do you check?
Look for wording such as magnesium, providing 200 milligrams, or elemental magnesium, in the nutrition panel.
Where only a compound weight appears, the elemental content is lower and the label is telling you less than it should.
Which minerals does this affect most?
Magnesium, calcium, zinc and iron, all of which are commonly supplemented and all of which come as several compounds.
Chelated forms such as bisglycinate typically contain a lower percentage of elemental mineral while being better absorbed.
What is the summary?
Compound weight and mineral content are different numbers, sometimes differing several fold, and the elemental figure is the only one worth comparing.
Why is this not clearer?
Because a larger number looks better, and the compound weight is a legitimate description of what the capsule contains.
Nothing prevents a manufacturer emphasising it, provided the nutrient amount also appears somewhere.
What is the practical rule?
Find the elemental figure, ignore the compound weight on the front, and compare products on that basis.
Where a label makes this hard to work out, that is worth noticing in itself.
How large can the difference be?
Nearly fourfold between magnesium oxide and citrate for the same compound weight, and around sevenfold for zinc gluconate against elemental zinc.
Those are not marginal differences.
They are enough to make one product effective and another close to pointless.
Does this apply to multivitamins?
Yes, and the amounts involved are usually small enough that the difference matters less.
It matters most for single mineral supplements taken at higher doses.
Magnesium is the one where people are most often misled.
Where does this catch people?
Most often with magnesium, where citrate products state large compound weights that correspond to modest elemental amounts.
Someone comparing two magnesium products on the front of the packet can easily choose the weaker one.
The panel resolves it immediately.
Anyone taking a mineral supplement should know which figure their product states.