Herbal labelling is considerably less standardised than vitamin labelling, which makes comparing products harder and more necessary.
What should be stated?
- The plant species, ideally with the botanical name
- The part used, since root, leaf and fruit differ chemically
- Whether it is whole herb powder or an extract
- The extraction ratio if it is an extract
- The standardised marker compound and its percentage
Why does plant part matter?
Because different parts contain different compounds in different amounts.
Ashwagandha root and root-with-leaf extracts differ meaningfully, as do valerian root and other parts of the same plant.
Research is usually conducted on one specific part, so a product using another does not correspond to it.
What is an extraction ratio?
A figure such as 10:1, meaning ten parts of raw plant material produced one part of extract.
A higher ratio means a more concentrated product, so 200 milligrams of a 10:1 extract corresponds to 2 grams of raw herb.
Ratios are not comparable between manufacturers, since extraction methods differ.
What is standardisation?
Guaranteeing a stated percentage of a specific marker compound, such as withanolides in ashwagandha or curcuminoids in turmeric.
This is the most useful figure, since it allows the actual active content to be calculated.
Multiply the extract weight by the stated percentage to get the amount of marker compound.
What about whole herb powder?
Dried ground plant material without concentration, containing far less active compound per gram than an extract.
Products stating a large milligram figure of whole herb are frequently supplying less active material than a smaller amount of extract.
What if the detail is missing?
Treat it as a product you cannot assess. Manufacturers who standardise generally say so prominently, since it costs more.
What is the summary?
Plant part, extract or powder, ratio and standardisation. Without them a milligram figure for a herbal ingredient means very little.
This article is general information and not medical advice.
What about solvents?
Extracts are made using water, alcohol or other solvents, which affects which compounds are extracted.
Better labels state the solvent, since a water extract and an alcohol extract of the same plant differ chemically.
What about native extract weight?
Some products state a total extract weight that includes carriers such as maltodextrin alongside the plant material.
The native extract figure is the plant derived portion and is the one worth comparing.
What is the summary?
Plant part, extract or powder, extraction ratio and standardisation. Without those, a milligram figure for a herbal ingredient means very little.
Why does this matter for safety?
Because a concentrated extract can supply many times the active compound of an apparently larger amount of powder.
Comparing on milligrams alone can therefore mislead in either direction.
What does a good herbal label look like?
Botanical name, plant part, extract ratio, solvent, standardised marker and percentage, and the native extract weight.
Very few products state all of these, and the ones that do are generally worth more attention.
Why is standardisation the key figure?
Because it is the only number allowing you to calculate how much active compound you are taking.
Extract weight without standardisation could correspond to almost any amount.
Research doses are almost always expressed in terms of the marker compound.
Can you compare two herbal products?
Only where both state standardisation, which allows the active compound amounts to be calculated and compared directly.
Without it, comparison is guesswork.
This is the main practical argument for choosing standardised products.
Why is herbal labelling so variable?
Because botanical claims and standards were never fully resolved in the regulatory framework, leaving considerable latitude in how products are described.
Better manufacturers state more than required.
That difference is easy to see once you know what to look for.
What is the practical approach?
Look for a stated percentage of a named marker compound, and calculate the actual amount from it.
Products without standardisation cannot be compared meaningfully.
That single check separates assessable products from unassessable ones.