Fat burner is a marketing term rather than a pharmacological category. What the products actually contain follows a fairly consistent pattern.
What is usually in them?
- Caffeine, often at high doses, sometimes from multiple sources
- Green tea extract, contributing both caffeine and EGCG
- Yohimbine, a stimulant with cardiovascular effects
- Synephrine from bitter orange, a stimulant related to ephedrine
- L-carnitine, with essentially no evidence for fat loss
- Garcinia cambogia, capsaicin extracts and various botanicals
- Chromium, marketed for cravings with weak evidence
Caffeine is doing whatever noticeable work these products do, and it is also the cheapest ingredient in them.
What does caffeine actually do?
It modestly increases energy expenditure and fat oxidation acutely, and tolerance to these effects develops with regular use.
The increase is small, and studies suggest habitual consumers show reduced thermogenic response over time.
It also reduces appetite somewhat in some people, which may contribute more than the metabolic effect.
What about the other stimulants?
Yohimbine can cause anxiety, raised blood pressure and palpitations, and interacts with several medicines.
Synephrine has structural similarity to ephedrine, which was withdrawn following serious adverse events. Its safety profile at supplement doses is debated.
Combining several stimulants produces effects that no single one would at the same dose.
Do they burn fat?
Increasing fat oxidation acutely does not produce fat loss unless total energy expenditure exceeds intake over time.
The body adjusts fuel use continuously, and shifting the proportion burned at a given moment has little bearing on body composition over weeks.
What are the risks?
Anxiety, insomnia, palpitations and raised blood pressure are common at higher stimulant doses.
This category also has a documented history of adulteration with prohibited substances.
Who should avoid them?
Anyone with heart disease, high blood pressure, anxiety disorders or thyroid conditions, and anyone taking regular medication without checking.
What is the summary?
Caffeine with expensive additions. If you want the caffeine effect, caffeine costs a fraction as much and lets you control the dose.
This article is general information and not medical advice.
How much caffeine is in them?
Frequently 200 to 400 milligrams per serving, sometimes across several sources listed separately so the total is not obvious.
Adding that to coffee and other sources can approach or exceed the 400 milligram daily figure European guidance considers acceptable.
What about carnitine?
L-carnitine transports fatty acids into mitochondria, which sounds directly relevant to fat burning.
Muscle carnitine is not usually limiting, and oral supplementation raises muscle levels poorly. Trials have found little effect on body composition.
What should you check?
Total caffeine content, the presence of yohimbine or synephrine, and whether amounts are disclosed rather than hidden in a blend.
Products concealing stimulant content are worth avoiding on safety grounds alone.
What is the summary?
Caffeine with expensive additions and, in some products, additional stimulants that add risk without adding evidence.
If the caffeine effect is what you want, caffeine costs a fraction as much and lets you control the dose precisely.
Do they work better with exercise?
Marketing frequently specifies that these products work alongside diet and exercise, which conveniently attributes any failure to the user.
Diet and exercise produce results without the supplement, which is the comparison that matters.
What about cycling them?
Products often recommend cycling to manage tolerance, which is an implicit acknowledgement that the effect is a stimulant one.
Tolerance to caffeine develops within days, which is why the noticeable effect fades quickly.
What about the pre-workout overlap?
Many fat burners are compositionally close to pre-workout products, differing mainly in marketing rather than in ingredients.
Anyone taking both is stacking stimulants without necessarily realising it, which is worth totalling.
Anyone considering one should total their caffeine from all sources first, since that figure usually answers the question about whether to add more.
Report any adverse reaction through the MHRA Yellow Card scheme, which accepts reports about supplements as well as medicines.
A pharmacist can advise on whether the stimulant content is appropriate alongside your medicines and health conditions.