Probiotics are defined internationally as live microorganisms which, when administered in adequate amounts, confer a health benefit on the host. Every part of that definition matters, and most products meet only some of it.
What is in a probiotic?
Usually bacteria from the Lactobacillus or Bifidobacterium groups, and sometimes a yeast called Saccharomyces boulardii.
Newer products use spore forming bacteria such as Bacillus coagulans, which survive stomach acid more readily.
The strain matters more than the species, which is the single most important thing to understand about this category.
Why does strain matter so much?
Two strains of the same species can behave completely differently, producing different compounds and interacting differently with the gut lining and immune system.
Evidence generated for one strain does not transfer to another, even one with a similar name.
A product listing only Lactobacillus acidophilus without a strain designation is telling you very little about what it might do.
Where is the evidence strongest?
- Preventing antibiotic associated diarrhoea, where several strains have reasonable support
- Reducing the duration of infectious diarrhoea in children
- Preventing necrotising enterocolitis in preterm infants, where evidence is substantial
- Pouchitis after certain bowel surgery
- Some irritable bowel syndrome symptoms, with specific strains
Where is it weak?
General gut health, immunity, mood, weight and skin, which is where most marketing focuses.
Studies exist in all of these areas, and they are typically small, use different strains and produce inconsistent results.
Do they colonise the gut?
Mostly not. Research tracking probiotic strains has found they generally pass through transiently rather than establishing permanently.
One study found substantial variation between individuals in whether strains colonised at all, with some people resistant regardless of dose.
This explains why benefits typically stop when supplementation stops.
Why can labels not make claims?
European and UK regulators have not approved health claims for probiotics, so the word itself cannot be used as a claim on packaging.
This is why products use vague language about digestive wellbeing rather than stating what they do.
What is the summary?
A genuine category with a few well supported uses, sold mainly on claims that are not well supported. Strain and dose determine whether a product has evidence behind it.
This article is general information and not medical advice.
How do they work if they pass through?
Several proposed mechanisms operate during transit rather than requiring permanent residence.
These include competing with pathogens for space and nutrients, producing compounds that inhibit other organisms, strengthening the gut barrier and interacting with immune tissue in the gut wall.
Some also produce enzymes such as lactase, which is one explanation for effects on lactose digestion.
Are they the same as fermented foods?
Not quite. Fermented foods contain live organisms, and those organisms have generally not been characterised or studied in the way probiotic strains have.
Fermented foods also supply fibre, protein and compounds produced during fermentation, which a capsule does not.
Who might benefit?
People taking antibiotics, those with IBS willing to trial a strain systematically, and specific clinical situations managed by a healthcare team.
Healthy people with no digestive complaints have the least to gain, which is also the group most heavily marketed to.
What should you look for?
A full strain designation, a stated dose in colony forming units per strain, and a guaranteed count at the end of shelf life rather than at manufacture.
Those three details separate products formulated around evidence from those formulated around a label.
What is the honest position?
Probiotics are neither the transformative product they are marketed as nor the placebo their critics suggest. They are a category with a few well evidenced uses and a great deal of speculative marketing on top.
Choosing on strain and dose rather than on packaging is what separates a reasonable purchase from a wasted one.
How does UK regulation treat them?
As food supplements rather than medicines, which means no pre-market approval of contents, purity or claims.
Manufacturers are responsible for safety, and enforcement is largely reactive, which places more weight on choosing established brands.