Getting live bacteria past the stomach is a genuine engineering problem. Gastric acid is designed to kill microorganisms, and it does so effectively.
What happens in the stomach?
Gastric pH can drop below 2 in the fasted state, which is lethal to most bacteria within minutes to hours.
Bile salts in the small intestine present a second challenge, damaging bacterial membranes.
Survival varies enormously between strains, with some losing the great majority of viable organisms during transit and others tolerating it far better.
How do manufacturers address it?
- Enteric coatings that resist stomach acid and dissolve in the small intestine
- Delayed release capsules using similar principles
- Spore forming bacteria such as Bacillus coagulans, naturally acid resistant
- Microencapsulation, coating individual organisms in a protective matrix
- Overdosing, supplying more organisms so enough survive
Why are spore formers different?
Certain bacteria form protective spores, essentially dormant structures resistant to heat, acid and drying.
They pass through the stomach in this state and germinate in the intestine, which makes them considerably more robust than conventional strains.
They also survive storage at room temperature, which is a practical advantage.
Does taking them with food help?
Yes. Food raises stomach pH and buffers acidity, which improves survival.
Research has suggested taking probiotics with or shortly before a meal containing some fat improves viability compared with taking them on an empty stomach.
Some products specify timing, and following the manufacturers instruction is sensible where it exists.
Does the yeast survive better?
Saccharomyces boulardii is a yeast and is naturally more resistant to gastric conditions than most bacterial strains.
It also resists antibiotics, which is why it is often used alongside antibiotic courses.
Does survival guarantee benefit?
No. Reaching the intestine alive is necessary rather than sufficient, since the organism must then do something useful.
Studies tracking probiotic strains have found most pass through without establishing residence, so any effect is exerted during transit.
What does this mean for buying?
Look for products stating the CFU count at the end of shelf life rather than at manufacture, since the difference can be substantial.
Delivery technology is worth something, and it matters less than whether the strain has evidence behind it at the dose supplied.
What is the summary?
Survival is a real problem, partly solved by coatings and spore formers. Taking them with food helps, and surviving transit is only the first requirement.
This article is general information and not medical advice.
Does the delivery method matter more than the strain?
No. A well delivered strain with no evidence behind it is still a strain with no evidence behind it.
Delivery matters as a secondary consideration once you have identified a strain and dose with published support.
Does stomach acid medication change things?
Proton pump inhibitors and other acid suppressing medicines raise gastric pH, which improves probiotic survival.
Long term acid suppression also alters the gut microbiome in its own right, and anyone taking these medicines long term should review them periodically with a GP.
How is survival measured?
Usually in laboratory models simulating gastric conditions, which approximate rather than replicate what happens in a person.
Studies recovering organisms from stool provide more direct evidence, and relatively few products have been tested this way.
What is the summary?
Survival varies widely by strain and is improved by coatings, spore forms and taking them with food. Reaching the intestine alive is the first hurdle rather than the finish line.
Does the format affect survival?
Capsules generally protect organisms better than powders or chewables, and delayed release capsules better still.
Liquid products face the greatest challenge, since organisms are metabolically active and decline faster than in a dried state.
Should you take them at a particular time?
With a meal is the general advice, since food buffers stomach acid and improves survival.
Where a manufacturer specifies timing, following it is sensible, since they may have tested the formulation under those conditions.