Collagen is a protein made by animals, which means a plant cannot contain it. Products marketed as vegan collagen are therefore something else, and understanding what is worth a minute of label reading.
Why can plants not contain collagen?
Collagen is produced by animal cells using a specific set of genes and enzymes that plants do not possess.
Plants have their own structural molecules including cellulose and lignin, which are chemically unrelated.
A product labelled vegan collagen contains no collagen, which is a straightforward matter of fact rather than a criticism.
What is in these products?
- Vitamin C, required as a cofactor for collagen synthesis
- Amino acids including glycine, proline and lysine
- Zinc and copper, involved in collagen formation and cross linking
- Plant extracts marketed for antioxidant properties
- Silica, sometimes from bamboo extract
- Hyaluronic acid in some products
These are generally described as collagen builders, which is a more accurate framing than vegan collagen.
Do collagen builders work?
The logic is that supplying the raw materials and cofactors supports the bodys own production.
The difficulty is that most people are not short of these. Glycine and proline are non-essential amino acids the body makes, and vitamin C deficiency is uncommon in the UK.
Supplying more of something that was not limiting does not increase output.
Is there any evidence?
Direct trials of vegan collagen builders are scarce compared with the collagen peptide research.
Where studies exist they are typically small, industry funded and use multi-ingredient products that cannot isolate any single component.
What about biosynthetic collagen?
Genuine collagen can be produced using genetically modified yeast or bacteria carrying human collagen genes, and this technology exists.
It is used mainly in cosmetics and biomedical applications rather than in oral supplements, and it is expensive.
This is the one route by which an animal free product could contain actual collagen, and it is not what most vegan collagen supplements are.
What should vegans do?
Ensure adequate total protein and vitamin C, protect skin from ultraviolet exposure, and consider topical retinoids if skin appearance is the goal.
Those have better evidence than either collagen peptides or their vegan alternatives.
What is the summary?
Vegan collagen products contain no collagen and supply cofactors most people already have enough of. The name is misleading rather than the products being harmful.
This article is general information and not medical advice.
Why is the labelling allowed?
Because the products do not claim to contain collagen in their ingredient lists, using the term as a category descriptor rather than an ingredient claim.
Reading the ingredients rather than the front of the packet resolves any confusion immediately.
Are they harmful?
Generally no. Vitamin C, zinc and amino acids at ordinary doses are well tolerated, and the objection is to the naming rather than the safety.
Zinc content is worth checking if you take other supplements, since long term intakes above 25 milligrams daily can deplete copper.
What is the summary?
Vegan collagen products contain no collagen and supply cofactors most people already have enough of. The name is the problem rather than the ingredients.
What should the label say?
An honest product describes itself as a collagen builder or support formula rather than as vegan collagen.
Checking the ingredient list for what is actually present takes a few seconds and settles it.
Is the technology promising?
Recombinant collagen produced by engineered microorganisms is a genuine and developing field, used in wound dressings and cosmetics.
Whether it reaches oral supplements at reasonable cost remains to be seen.
What do the amino acids contribute?
Glycine and proline are non-essential, meaning the body synthesises them, so supplying more is unlikely to be limiting in anyone eating adequate protein.
Lysine is essential and readily obtained from ordinary dietary protein.
Anyone choosing between these and a collagen peptide product should recognise they are buying quite different things despite the similarity of the names on the front.