Ashwagandha has developed a following in strength training, based on a small number of trials that produced striking results and have not been extensively replicated.
What did the trials find?
A frequently cited study gave 300 milligrams of root extract twice daily to men undertaking an eight week resistance programme.
The supplement group showed greater increases in bench press and leg extension strength, greater increases in muscle size, and higher testosterone than placebo.
The study included fewer than 60 participants, which is small for detecting effects of this kind.
Has it been replicated?
Some further trials have reported improvements in strength, power and recovery markers, though the literature remains small.
Reviews have generally described the evidence as preliminary and called for larger independent trials.
What about endurance?
Some studies have reported improvements in maximal oxygen uptake in athletes and healthy adults.
Findings have been inconsistent and sample sizes small, as with the strength research.
What might the mechanism be?
Proposed mechanisms include reduced cortisol, improved recovery, reduced muscle damage markers and possible effects on testosterone.
Improved sleep would also plausibly improve training adaptation, which may account for part of any effect.
How does it compare with established supplements?
- Creatine has hundreds of trials and consistent effects on strength and lean mass
- Caffeine has extensive evidence for acute performance
- Adequate protein at 1.6 grams per kilogram has strong supporting evidence
- Ashwagandha has a handful of small trials by comparison
Anyone choosing where to spend money on training supplements should work down that list in order.
Would it help without training?
No. The trials combined it with a resistance programme, and the programme is what produces the adaptation.
No supplement builds meaningful muscle in the absence of a progressive training stimulus, whatever the marketing suggests.
Is it worth trying?
Reasonable for someone who has already addressed training, protein, sleep and creatine and wants to try something further.
It should not be a first purchase, and expectations should be modest given the size of the literature.
What is the summary?
A few small promising trials, limited replication, and a long way behind creatine in evidence. Interesting rather than established.
This article is general information and not medical advice.
What about recovery markers?
Some trials have reported reduced creatine kinase after exercise, suggesting less muscle damage, alongside subjective recovery measures.
These are secondary findings in small studies and should be treated as preliminary.
Would sleep explain part of it?
Plausibly. Better sleep improves training adaptation, and any supplement that improves sleep might improve strength outcomes indirectly.
Trials have generally not separated these pathways, which makes attribution difficult.
What is the summary?
A few small promising trials with limited replication, far behind creatine and protein in evidence, and worth considering only after those are in place.
Does it help endurance athletes?
Some trials have reported improvements in maximal oxygen uptake, with small samples and inconsistent findings across studies.
The evidence is thinner than for strength, which is itself thin.
Where does it sit in priority?
After training programming, protein intake, sleep and creatine, all of which have substantially stronger evidence and lower cost.
It is a reasonable experiment for someone who has already covered those, and a poor first purchase.
What about combining it with creatine?
No interaction is established, and the two work through entirely different mechanisms, so combining them is unproblematic.
Starting both at once makes it impossible to attribute any change, which is worth considering if you want to know what is working.
What produces the gains?
The training programme, in every one of these trials. Participants who took the supplement without training were not included, because that is not how muscle is built.
Any supplement effect sits on top of a training stimulus that does the actual work of building strength and muscle.
Anyone deciding where to spend money on training supplements has better evidenced options available at lower cost than this one.