The thyroid effect is one of the more specific and better characterised properties of ashwagandha, and it cuts both ways depending on your circumstances.
What does it do to thyroid hormones?
Animal studies have consistently found increases in T4 and T3 with ashwagandha administration.
A human trial in people with subclinical hypothyroidism reported normalisation of thyroid stimulating hormone alongside increases in T3 and T4.
This is one of the few ashwagandha effects with a reasonably consistent mechanism across animal and human research.
Is that a benefit or a risk?
It depends entirely on your thyroid status. For someone with subclinical hypothyroidism it might be desirable, and it is not an established treatment.
For someone with an overactive thyroid, or someone taking levothyroxine at a stable dose, it is a potential problem.
What has been reported?
Case reports have described thyrotoxicosis associated with ashwagandha, with symptoms resolving after stopping the supplement.
Cases have also described people on levothyroxine developing symptoms of excess thyroid hormone after starting ashwagandha.
What are the symptoms of excess?
- Palpitations and a rapid heart rate
- Feeling hot and sweating excessively
- Anxiety, restlessness and tremor
- Unintended weight loss despite normal appetite
- Difficulty sleeping
- Loose bowels
Anyone developing these while taking ashwagandha should stop it and speak to a GP.
Who should avoid it?
Anyone with hyperthyroidism or Graves disease. Anyone taking levothyroxine or antithyroid medication without discussing it first.
People with autoimmune thyroid disease, given both the hormonal effect and theoretical immune stimulation.
Anyone with a thyroid condition should discuss it with whoever manages their treatment rather than starting independently.
Does it affect thyroid blood tests?
It can change the values, which means a test taken while on it may not reflect your usual status.
Mention it before thyroid function testing, since an unexplained abnormal result may otherwise prompt unnecessary investigation or dose changes.
What was the regulatory concern?
Thyroid effects featured in the risk assessment that led one European country to restrict ashwagandha in supplements.
What is the summary?
A genuine hormonal effect that makes this supplement unsuitable for anyone with thyroid disease without medical advice.
This article is general information and not medical advice.
Should you have thyroid tests?
Anyone with a known thyroid condition taking ashwagandha should have function monitored, and this is a conversation to have before starting rather than after.
For people with no thyroid history, routine testing is not generally indicated unless symptoms develop.
Does it interact with levothyroxine?
Potentially, since raising endogenous thyroid hormone while taking replacement could produce excess.
Anyone on levothyroxine should discuss it with their GP rather than adding it and watching for symptoms.
What is the summary?
A real hormonal effect that makes ashwagandha unsuitable for anyone with thyroid disease or on thyroid medication without medical advice.
Mention it before thyroid function testing, since it can alter the results.
What about subclinical hypothyroidism?
A trial reported normalisation of thyroid values in this group, which is interesting and not a basis for self treatment.
Subclinical hypothyroidism is managed through monitoring and sometimes treatment, both of which require blood tests rather than a supplement.
Is the effect consistent?
The direction is consistent across animal and human research, and the magnitude varies and has mainly been studied in small samples.
Consistency of direction is what makes this caution firmer than most supplement warnings.
Who should have this conversation?
Anyone with a thyroid diagnosis, anyone on levothyroxine, and anyone with a family history of thyroid disease considering starting it.
The conversation is short and prevents a problem that has been documented in case reports.
What about people with no thyroid history?
The effect has been documented mainly in people with existing thyroid conditions or in animal models at higher doses.
Symptoms of excess thyroid hormone in anyone taking it are still worth acting on promptly.
Thyroid symptoms are easy to attribute to stress or ageing, which is why knowing the supplement can cause them matters.