Back to Performance

What Causes Delayed Onset Muscle Soreness?

What Causes Delayed Onset Muscle Soreness?
Supplements Guide 16 February 2026

Delayed onset muscle soreness is one of the most familiar training experiences and one of the most persistently misexplained. The lactic acid story is wrong, and the actual mechanism is more interesting.

Why is lactic acid not the cause?

Because lactate is cleared from muscle and blood within roughly an hour of exercise finishing.

Soreness peaks 24 to 72 hours later, long after any lactate has gone. The timing alone rules it out.

Lactate is also not the villain it was made out to be, functioning as a fuel that muscle and other tissues use rather than as a waste product.

What does cause it?

Microscopic damage to muscle fibres and connective tissue, followed by an inflammatory response.

That inflammation involves immune cell infiltration, swelling and the release of substances that sensitise pain receptors in the affected tissue.

The soreness is therefore partly damage and partly altered pain sensitivity, which is why light pressure on a sore muscle hurts disproportionately.

Why do eccentric contractions cause it most?

Eccentric contractions occur when a muscle lengthens under load, such as lowering a weight or running downhill.

Fewer muscle fibres are recruited to handle the same load, so each bears more force, which produces more mechanical disruption.

This is why downhill running, the lowering phase of lifts and unfamiliar plyometric work produce disproportionate soreness.

What is the repeated bout effect?

After one exposure to an unfamiliar eccentric exercise, subsequent sessions produce far less soreness and damage.

The protection develops quickly, lasts weeks to months, and involves adaptations in muscle structure, neural recruitment and connective tissue.

It explains why the first session back after a break is disproportionately painful and the second is not.

Is soreness a sign of a good session?

No, and this is worth stating clearly. Soreness reflects novelty and eccentric loading rather than training quality.

Studies have found dissociation between soreness and actual recovery of force, and between soreness and muscle growth.

Someone training consistently and progressing well may experience very little soreness.

When should soreness concern you?

  • Severe soreness with dark or cola coloured urine, which needs urgent medical assessment
  • Sharp or localised pain rather than diffuse aching
  • Swelling that is marked or asymmetrical
  • Soreness persisting beyond about a week
  • Any loss of function that does not improve

The first of these can indicate rhabdomyolysis, which is uncommon and serious.

What reduces it?

Gradual progression above all, since novelty drives it. Light activity often eases stiffness. Time resolves it regardless.

What is the summary?

Eccentric damage and inflammation, not lactic acid. It is a poor guide to training quality and largely prevented by progressing sensibly.

This article is general information and not medical advice.

Does it mean damage that needs fixing?

The damage is microscopic and part of a normal remodelling process rather than injury. It resolves without intervention and contributes to adaptation.

This is one reason aggressively suppressing the inflammatory response afterwards may be counterproductive.

Does soreness fade with training?

Substantially. Trained individuals doing familiar work experience far less soreness than beginners or than anyone returning after a break.

That is the repeated bout effect operating continuously, and it is why experienced trainees can work hard without much soreness.

What is the summary?

Eccentric damage and the inflammatory response to it, peaking at 24 to 72 hours. Not lactic acid, and not a measure of whether training worked.

The repeated bout effect means the same session will hurt far less next time, which is the most reliable prevention available.

Does it happen to everyone equally?

No. Susceptibility varies considerably between individuals, partly genetically, and some people experience very little soreness from work that leaves others struggling.

That variation makes soreness an even poorer basis for comparing training between people.

Can you train while sore?

Generally yes, provided it is diffuse aching rather than sharp pain and performance is not substantially reduced.

Training the same muscle heavily while still markedly sore is more questionable, since force production may still be impaired.