This is one of the more counterintuitive findings in sports nutrition and one of the more important. Suppressing the oxidative stress that training produces appears to suppress some of the adaptations it drives.
What is the underlying idea?
Exercise generates reactive oxygen species, which were long regarded as damage to be minimised.
Research has established that these molecules also act as signals, triggering the cellular pathways that produce adaptation, including mitochondrial biogenesis and antioxidant enzyme production.
Blocking the signal blocks part of the response, which is the basis of the concern about high dose antioxidant supplementation.
What did the studies find?
A well known study gave vitamin C and E during endurance training and found blunted improvements in markers of mitochondrial biogenesis compared with placebo.
Another examining resistance training in older adults found reduced gains in muscle strength with high dose vitamin C and E supplementation.
Further research has reported interference with insulin sensitivity improvements from exercise.
Not every study has found interference, and the pattern is consistent enough to have changed guidance.
Which supplements are involved?
- High dose vitamin C, typically 1000mg daily in the studies
- High dose vitamin E, often 235 to 400 IU
- The combination, which is what most studies used
- Possibly other high dose isolated antioxidants
The concern applies to large isolated doses rather than to the amounts found in food.
Does food have the same effect?
No evidence suggests it does. Antioxidants in fruit and vegetables arrive in far smaller quantities, alongside fibre and other compounds, and in a food matrix.
Diets rich in these foods are associated with favourable health outcomes, and no one is suggesting reducing fruit and vegetable intake.
What about tart cherry and polyphenols?
Less clear. These are polyphenols rather than isolated vitamins, and whether they interfere similarly has not been established.
A cautious approach uses them around competition rather than continuously through a training block, which captures the recovery benefit without extended suppression.
Does this apply to anti-inflammatories?
A related concern exists for regular use of non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs after training, with some research suggesting blunted muscle adaptations.
Occasional use for pain is different from routine prophylactic use, and anyone taking them regularly should discuss it with a GP.
What should you do?
Get antioxidants from food, avoid high dose isolated antioxidant supplements around training periods, and reserve any anti-inflammatory approach for when recovering quickly matters more than adapting.
What is the summary?
The stress is part of the signal. High dose antioxidants interfere with adaptation, food does not, and this is one of the clearer cases where more is worse.
This article is general information and not medical advice.
What is hormesis?
The principle that a moderate stress produces an adaptive response that leaves the system stronger than before.
Exercise is a clear example, and it explains why removing the stress removes the adaptation. The discomfort is not incidental to the process.
Does timing help?
Some suggest taking antioxidant supplements away from training sessions to allow the signalling to occur. Evidence for a safe interval is limited.
Given that food based antioxidants appear unproblematic, the simpler approach is to get them from food.
What is the summary?
High dose isolated antioxidants interfere with the signalling that produces adaptation. Food based antioxidants do not appear to.
This is one of the clearer examples in nutrition where taking more of something beneficial produces a worse outcome.
Does this mean avoiding vitamin C entirely?
No. Meeting requirements through food is important, and the concern applies to gram scale supplemental doses rather than dietary amounts.
Someone taking a multivitamin containing modest amounts is in a different position from someone taking 1000mg daily.
What about anti-inflammatory foods?
The concern applies to concentrated supplemental doses rather than to dietary patterns. Nobody has suggested that eating vegetables impairs training adaptation.
The distinction between food and isolated high dose supplements runs through most of this area.
Athletes in competition periods, where recovering quickly matters more than adapting, are the group with the clearest case for using them at all.