Loose stools are the most common side effect of magnesium supplements and the reason many people stop taking them. The mechanism is simple osmosis, and it is entirely predictable from which form and dose you have chosen.
What is actually happening?
Magnesium absorption from the gut is limited and becomes proportionally less efficient as the dose increases. Whatever is not absorbed remains in the intestine.
Magnesium ions in the bowel draw water in by osmosis, increasing the volume of intestinal contents. That extra fluid softens stool and stimulates movement through the bowel.
This is not a malfunction. It is exactly the principle behind magnesium based laxatives such as milk of magnesia and magnesium citrate preparations used to clear the bowel before procedures.
Why do some forms cause it more?
Because absorption varies considerably between forms, and poorly absorbed forms leave more magnesium behind.
Magnesium oxide is absorbed at only a few per cent, so the great majority stays in the gut. Magnesium sulfate, Epsom salts, is similar and is used deliberately as a laxative.
Citrate is better absorbed but still moderately laxative. Glycinate and malate are better absorbed and considerably gentler.
How can you reduce the effect?
- Switch to magnesium glycinate or bisglycinate, the gentlest common form
- Split the dose across the day rather than taking it all at once
- Take it with food, which slows transit and reduces the effect
- Reduce the total dose, since absorption is proportionally better at lower amounts
- Build up gradually rather than starting at a full dose
Splitting is the most effective single change, since it improves absorption and reduces the amount left in the gut at any one time.
Is the diarrhoea harmful?
Occasional loose stools from a supplement are not dangerous in themselves. Persistent diarrhoea is worth taking seriously, because it causes loss of fluid and other electrolytes including potassium.
There is also a certain irony in losing magnesium through diarrhoea caused by taking magnesium, which is a real effect at high doses.
If loose stools persist after adjusting form and dose, stop and see a GP rather than continuing, since something else may be going on.
Can the effect be useful?
Yes, and it is used deliberately. Magnesium containing laxatives are established treatments for constipation, and magnesium citrate is used for bowel preparation before colonoscopy.
If you have both low magnesium and constipation, citrate or oxide may suit you better than glycinate, since you get both effects from one product.
Does tolerance develop?
Often, at least partly. Many people find the bowel effect settles after one to two weeks of consistent use at the same dose.
Starting low and increasing gradually over a couple of weeks generally avoids the worst of it, which is a better approach than beginning at a full dose and abandoning it after three days.
What dose causes it?
Highly variable between individuals, and guidance sets an upper level of around 400 milligrams a day from supplements largely on this basis, with some bodies setting 250 milligrams for readily dissolving salts.
Some people experience effects well below that, particularly with oxide, while others tolerate more without difficulty.
Anyone with kidney disease should not take magnesium supplements without medical advice, since the kidneys are what clear it. This article is general information and not medical advice.
Does it mean you are absorbing nothing?
No. Some magnesium is absorbed even from poorly absorbed forms, and the diarrhoea reflects the proportion that was not rather than a total failure.
It does mean you are getting considerably less than the label number suggests, which is the practical argument for a better absorbed form rather than a larger dose of a cheap one.
What if you need magnesium but cannot tolerate it?
Glycinate at a modest dose, split across the day and taken with food, resolves it for most people. Increasing dietary magnesium through nuts, seeds and greens avoids the problem entirely.
Food magnesium does not cause this effect at normal intakes, because it is absorbed more gradually and arrives in smaller amounts at a time.