Magnesium is sold in more forms than almost any other supplement, and unlike most such comparisons, the differences here are genuine. Absorption varies several fold between forms, and so does the tendency to cause diarrhoea.
What are the main forms?
- Magnesium oxide, cheap, high in elemental magnesium, poorly absorbed
- Magnesium citrate, well absorbed, moderately laxative, inexpensive
- Magnesium glycinate or bisglycinate, well absorbed and gentle on the gut
- Magnesium malate, well absorbed, sometimes marketed for fatigue
- Magnesium L-threonate, expensive, marketed for cognition
- Magnesium chloride, well absorbed, also used in topical products
- Magnesium sulfate, Epsom salts, used in baths and as a laxative
- Magnesium taurate, promoted for cardiovascular use with limited evidence
Why is oxide so common if it absorbs poorly?
Because it is cheap and contains a high proportion of elemental magnesium by weight, which lets a label show a large number.
Absorption studies have found magnesium oxide absorbed at only a few per cent, considerably less than citrate or organic salts. Most of it stays in the gut, drawing water in, which is why it works as a laxative.
If a product does not state the form, it is usually oxide. It is not useless, particularly if constipation is the goal, and it is a poor choice for raising magnesium status.
What is elemental magnesium?
This is the number that matters and the one most often obscured. Magnesium compounds contain magnesium bound to something else, and only the magnesium portion counts.
A 500 milligram magnesium citrate tablet does not supply 500 milligrams of magnesium. Depending on the compound it might supply somewhere between roughly 10 and 60 per cent of that weight.
Glycinate is particularly low in elemental content by weight, which means glycinate products often need larger or more numerous capsules to deliver a useful dose.
Is citrate or glycinate better?
Both are well absorbed and the choice comes down to tolerance and purpose.
Citrate is inexpensive, well studied and mildly laxative, which suits anyone who also wants help with constipation. Glycinate is gentler on the gut and is the usual choice for people who found citrate loosening.
Glycinate dominates the sleep market partly because glycine itself may have mild sleep effects, though no trial has shown it outperforms other forms for that purpose.
What about magnesium L-threonate?
This is the most expensive form and is marketed on the claim that it crosses the blood brain barrier more effectively and raises magnesium levels in brain tissue.
The supporting evidence comes largely from animal research plus a small human trial reporting cognitive improvements. That is a thin foundation for a substantial price premium.
It also contains a low proportion of elemental magnesium, so a large capsule delivers a modest dose.
Which should you actually buy?
Magnesium citrate is the sensible default for most people, being well absorbed, cheap and well studied. Switch to glycinate if citrate loosens your bowels or if you are taking it in the evening and want the gentlest option.
Choose oxide only if you want the laxative effect. Avoid paying a premium for threonate or taurate unless you have a specific reason and accept that the evidence is limited.
What should you check on the label?
The form, the elemental magnesium content per serving, and the serving size, since some products require several capsules.
Keep supplemental intake at or below roughly 400 milligrams of elemental magnesium daily unless advised otherwise. Anyone with kidney disease should not supplement without medical advice.
This article is general information and not medical advice.
Does the marketing around forms hold up?
Partly. The absorption differences between oxide and the organic salts are real and well documented, which is unusual for supplement form claims.
The claims distinguishing citrate from glycinate from malate are much weaker. All three absorb reasonably well, and the differences between them are small compared with the gap between any of them and oxide.
What about combined products?
Magnesium is frequently sold with vitamin B6, zinc or other ingredients. Check the B6 content specifically, since UK advice suggests keeping supplemental B6 at or below 10 milligrams daily and some products contain considerably more.
Combined products also make it harder to tell what is responsible if you notice an effect, which matters if you are trying something to see whether it helps.